Buying a car as a graduation gift should be a joyful milestone — but for Tiffany Searight it turned into months of frustration, long drives and repeated trips across New York. What began as a well-intentioned surprise for her son drew the attention of reporters, regulators and others who recognized a cautionary tale about buying a vehicle from a distance.
Graduation Gift with Good Intentions
Credit: iStockphoto
Searight, a single mother who had already helped one child through college and worked two jobs to support her family, wanted to surprise her youngest son after he graduated high school. She found a car listed online at a Long Island dealership and drove more than six hours from the Rochester area to buy it, planning to complete financing, leave the car for service, and return later to pick it up.
A Long Drive and a Signed Deal
Credit: pexels
Records show Searight paid a $3,300 deposit and signed paperwork for financing through Westlake Financial. The trip covered roughly 400 miles each way. Rather than driving the car home, she was told it needed some maintenance before delivery — a delay she accepted at the time, expecting a short wait.
The Car That Never Seemed Ready
Credit: pexels
Days turned into weeks and the explanations kept changing. Emails reviewed by reporters show the dealership cited an oil change, then a weak pulley, then a sensor issue. None of those updates produced the car. The shifting list of problems felt less like routine servicing and more like a moving target that kept the vehicle out of reach.
An Unexpected Return Trip
Credit: pexels
Frustrated, Searight drove back to Long Island on January 12. When she arrived the vehicle reportedly was not even on the lot. That discovery increased her concern and prompted her to seek help from local authorities to get answers about the missing car and the sale.
Loan Payments Arrive Anyway
Credit: iStockphoto
In February the situation took a surprising turn: financing payments became due even though Searight still did not have the car. That disconnect is central to her complaint — typically, loan payments follow a completed sale and delivery. In this case, billing began before the vehicle ever reached her, leaving her responsible for payments on a car she hadn’t taken possession of.
A Credit Score Hanging in the Balance
Credit: pexels
Searight worried about damage to her credit after years of careful financial management. Missed or disputed payments can reduce credit scores, and consumers with stronger histories can sometimes see larger-than-expected point drops. That risk amplified the stress of an already unresolved transaction.
A Fraud Review Adds Another Twist
Credit: pexels
Emails show Westlake Financial opened a fraud review on the account, even as the loan remained active and financing charges continued to be assessed. The review acknowledged concerns about the transaction, but it did not immediately resolve the apparent mismatch between billing and delivery, leaving Searight in limbo.
A Story That Reached Television News
Credit: pexels
After months without resolution, Searight turned to CBS News New York. Investigative reporter Mahsa Saeidi reviewed the case and accompanied Searight back to the dealership. What began as a private dispute became a broader consumer story, highlighting the challenges buyers can face when a purchase, financing and delivery do not align.
Movement at Last
Credit: iStockphoto
The visit produced tangible results. Reports say the dealership provided a shipping label, issued a $3,300 refund check via FedEx and gave Searight $400 to cover travel expenses. A document canceling the purchase was drafted during the meeting. After months of uncertainty, the dealership took concrete steps to resolve the matter.
A Better Ending Than It First Appeared
Credit: pexels
Weeks later Searight confirmed the refund check had cleared and that the account linked to the transaction had been removed from credit reports. Her son eventually acquired a vehicle, though not the one originally planned. The New York State Department of Motor Vehicles has confirmed an open investigation into the dealership, and the case serves as a reminder of the value of vigilance when buying a car from afar.