Giving thanks is always meaningful, and there’s a special moment each year when it’s time to bring out Thanksgiving decorations. Often treasured pieces are handed down through families, and those heirloom centerpieces, plates and figurines may be worth far more than you expect. Below is a curated list of the most valuable Thanksgiving collectibles, updated and written in clear, polished English. Each entry includes a brief description, estimated value, and why collectors prize it.
40. Vintage Thanksgiving Postcard With Pilgrim and Native American Children
laukie14 / eBay
Value: $51
Why it’s valuable: Postmarked 1910, this standard-size postcard features festively dressed Pilgrims and Native American children beside a giant pumpkin. Its over-a-century-old condition shows minor corner wear, which adds to its vintage charm.
39. Vintage Hallmark Die-Cut Thanksgiving 3D Pop-Up Card Decor Centerpiece
mightypen-us / eBay
Value: $59.99
Why it’s valuable: Unlike typical centerpieces made from wood, metal or straw, this rare Hallmark die-cut centerpiece is constructed from thin cardboard lithograph printed in Japan. It’s mostly intact, with only some edge wear.
38. Vintage Lefton Thanksgiving Salt and Pepper Shakers
antiquejulie / eBay
Value: $65
Why it’s valuable: This ceramic set from Lefton, dated 1956, was discovered at an estate sale. Despite a small crack around the middle, the shakers sold for significantly more than their original price thanks to their collectible status.
37. Retro L.E. Smith Glass Thanksgiving Turkey Dishes
josua-3083 / eBay
Value: $74
Why it’s valuable: These crystal turkeys, likely from the 1980s or 1990s, are intricately etched and large enough to serve cranberry sauce, gravy or stuffing. Their attractive design and excellent condition make them desirable for collectors.
36. Vintage 10-Piece Resin Children Celebrating Thanksgiving Figurines
magdas1967 / eBay
Value: $84.99
Why it’s valuable: Although made in 2007, this brightly painted 10-piece resin set was modeled after 1930s American decorations. Each figure stands around six inches tall, and the nostalgic style appeals to collectors seeking folk-inspired holiday pieces.
35. Vintage November Turkey Elf Fall Figurine
mykittenswearmittens / eBay
Value: $88
Why it’s valuable: Produced by Napco, this charming figurine likely dates to the 1950s. Its cheerful expression and solid vintage appeal make it a beloved little accent for holiday displays.
33. Vintage Holland Turkey Centerpiece (Tie)
circa-holiday / eBay
Value: $89.99
Why it’s valuable: This large ceramic centerpiece measures about 17 by 16 inches with real turkey feathers in its tail. Dating to the 1960s, the combination of scale and authentic feather detailing increases its collector value.
33. Vintage 20-Inch Turkey Platter (Tie)
christinescloset12 / eBay
Value: $89.99
Why it’s valuable: This 1950s platter made in Turkey shows a few chips on the underside rim that aren’t visible from above. Its origin and era help explain its market value despite minor imperfections.
32. Six Vintage Sabin Warranted 22k Rim Thanksgiving Dinner Plates
blueprinter1995 / eBay
Value: $90
Why it’s valuable: This six-piece set of 10-inch dinner plates features 22k gold rims and a plump turkey motif. Made in the 1970s, the luxurious trim and vintage appeal give these plates added value.
31. Vintage Thanksgiving Die-Cut Beistle Decorations
alexissarty3077 / eBay
Value: $94.95
Why it’s valuable: This collection included 20 die-cut pieces from 1950s-era brands like Beistle, Hallmark and Peanuts. The set’s breadth and preserved condition make it appealing to collectors of paper holiday decor.
29. Vintage Thanksgiving Dinner Pilgrim and Native American Figurine Set (Tie)
fishon789 / eBay
Value: $95
Why it’s valuable: This charming wooden set includes multiple full-size and small Pilgrim figures, six Native Americans, a boat and a Thanksgiving table. Its detailed miniature presentation makes it a sought-after collectible.
29. Vintage Paper Mache Thanksgiving Mini Turkey Candy Container (Tie)
goodolddays64 / eBay
Value: $95
Why it’s valuable: This spring-neck bobblehead turkey dates to 1930s Germany and stands under three inches tall. Its playful movement and excellent condition helped it sell for nearly $100.
28. Ceramic Hand-Painted First Thanksgiving Set
3millie4 / eBay
Value: $99.99
Why it’s valuable: Made in the 1980s, this detailed hand-painted set re-creates the first Thanksgiving with Pilgrim and Native American couples, a dog and cat, and a feast-laden table. Its craftsmanship and vintage status drive collector interest.
27. Vintage Thanksgiving Melted Popcorn Decorations
mamamonkeyof4 / eBay
Value: $100
Why it’s valuable: Popular in the 1960s, these vibrant melted popcorn decorations included multiple Native American figures and a Pilgrim girl. Their vivid colors and excellent used condition preserved their value.
26. Vintage Norcrest Japan Thanksgiving Pilgrims Salt and Pepper Shakers
dede123beagle / eBay
Value: $102.50
Why it’s valuable: These 1950s Norcrest shakers are roughly 4.25 inches tall and were sold in nearly perfect condition, with only a small paint chip on a pumpkin detail. Their age and design boost their desirability.
25. Vintage Kreiss Pilgrim Ceramic Figurines
eagerlyeclectic / eBay
Value: $105.50
Why it’s valuable: These two Kreiss pilgrim figurines, made in 1956, show minimal wear and retain the classic style of midcentury holiday ceramics, making them attractive to collectors.
24. Royal Stafford Harvest Dinner Plates
mymymonday08 / eBay
Value: $115
Why it’s valuable: This set of eight 11-inch plates from Royal Stafford (England) is both decorative and practical—microwaveable and dishwasher safe—making it appealing for display and use.
23. Rare Pumpkin Head Scarecrow Figures
basicsthriftstore / eBay
Value: $120
Why it’s valuable: Likely made by Sarco in 1950s Japan, these 12-inch figures feature celluloid heads, felt and straw bodies, and fixed poses that make them hug their knees. Their rarity and whimsical construction drive collector interest.
22. Vintage Thanksgiving Greetings Postcard
dolejuiceguy / eBay
Value: $120.50
Why it’s valuable: This 1945 “Thanksgiving Greetings, Aloha from Hawaii” postcard is uncommon and was sold in pristine condition, which explains its strong market price for collectors of vintage ephemera.
21. Vintage Mark Roberts Large Happy Thanksgiving Elf
stancilsantiquesunlimited / eBay
Value: $124.99
Why it’s valuable: This cheerful eight-inch elf, made by Mark Roberts in 2011 and sold with its original tag, captures a playful November vibe and appeals to collectors of designer holiday figurines.
20. Don Featherstone Blow Mold Turkey
norwichlov / eBay
Value: $129
Why it’s valuable: Produced by Union Products in the 1980s and signed by designer Don Featherstone, this two-foot blow mold still had its working light cord and bulb and avoided outdoor weathering, preserving bright colors.
19. Norcrest Thanksgiving Pilgrims Salt and Pepper Shakers
dede123beagle / eBay
Value: $132.50
Why it’s valuable: This 1950s pair from Norcrest includes Pilgrim figures with only minor chips. Their completeness and attractive styling make them valuable both for display and occasional use.
18. Vintage House of Hatten Pilgrim Set
beamthrift / eBay
Value: $139
Why it’s valuable: Hand-carved and painted in 1995, these 15-inch Pilgrim decorations display fine craftsmanship. Minor discoloration doesn’t detract from their handcrafted appeal to collectors.
17. Bethany Lowe Thanksgiving Boy
holidaytreasuresforyou / eBay
Value: $139.95
Why it’s valuable: Bethany Lowe’s whimsical designs are highly collectible. This roughly 11.5-inch folk-art piece shows a sailor boy riding a turkey and exemplifies the brand’s quirky holiday aesthetic.
16. Huge 40-Inch Turkey Yard Decoration
curt_corn / eBay
Value: $149.99
Why it’s valuable: This oversized 40-inch stuffed turkey intended for outdoor or patio display is memorable for its unusual costume—dressed as a Pilgrim—and its dramatic scale makes it a standout yard piece.
15. Queens Myott Thanksgiving Turkey Plates
poshinthepalms / eBay
Value: $150
Why it’s valuable: Made of fine porcelain in the United Kingdom, this six-piece set sold despite small glaze imperfections. Its porcelain quality and decorative turkey motif appeal to collectors of vintage tableware.
14. Vintage Byers’ Choice Native American Carolers Set
rosenu / eBay
Value: $160
Why it’s valuable: Byers’ Choice is known for finely detailed carolers. This 2004 pair of 13-inch Native American carolers includes miniature pottery and a tiny bow and arrow, demonstrating the brand’s meticulous detail work.
13. Vintage Johnson Brothers Home for Thanksgiving Platter
july10 / eBay
Value: $169
Why it’s valuable: Johnson Brothers’ 20-inch platter titled “Home for Thanksgiving” mixes seasonal imagery with a central turkey figure. As a product from a historic British manufacturer, it appeals to collectors of vintage serving ware.
12. Vintage Thanksgiving Turkey Blow Mold
fantasticfindspastnpresent / eBay
Value: $174.99
Why it’s valuable: Blow molds were immensely popular because they light up and glow. This Don Featherstone-designed piece from earlier decades still worked and, aside from mild paint loss on the head, remained in strong condition.
11. Vintage Turkey Yard Art
lab1967 / eBay
Value: $194.99
Why it’s valuable: This nearly three-foot tall hand-painted sign from the Winfield Collection was sealed for weather resistance and stands out for its humorous, hand-crafted aesthetic. Large, hand-decorated pieces like this draw attention in the market.
10. Vintage Royal Doulton Thanksgiving Turkey Dinner Plates
unique2sell / eBay
Value: $199
Why it’s valuable: Likely dating to the 1940s or 1950s, this set of four vibrant 10.25-inch Royal Doulton plates features multiple turkey motifs. Given their age and decorative appeal, they are better suited to display than daily use.
9. Byers’ Choice Pilgrim Carolers
orange-clove / eBay
Value: $199.99
Why it’s valuable: These retired 13-inch Pilgrim carolers from 1996 are difficult to find, and their lifelike, detailed construction keeps demand high among collectors of Byers’ Choice figures.
8. Vintage Thanksgiving Candy Container
pumpkinpiepantry / eBay
Value: $225.99
Why it’s valuable: This colorful six-inch turkey candy container from 1950s Germany features a plaster body and metal feet. Its bright finish and excellent condition make it both decorative and collectible.
7. Mason’s English Ironstone Turkey Serving Platter
ar_ti_fact / eBay
Value: $234.50
Why it’s valuable: Dating to the 1930s, this 19-by-15-inch Mason’s English Ironstone platter shows little sign of use. Its age, size and condition make it a standout piece for serious collectors of vintage serving ware.
6. Vintage Stained Glass Tiffany-Style Turkey Lamp
silkroadtreasuretrove2 / eBay
Value: $245
Why it’s valuable: This 12-inch Tiffany-style stained glass turkey lamp from the 1990s glows in warm jewel tones when lit. Its mint condition and atmospheric appeal make it a prized piece for vintage lighting and holiday decor collectors.
5. Vintage Folk Art Thanksgiving Straw Turkey Centerpiece
strategic-genesis / eBay
Value: $295
Why it’s valuable: This elaborate piece of folk art is constructed from straw and genuine turkey feathers and measures about 40 by 38 inches. Its incredible scale, handmade detail and rustic appeal place it high among collectible centerpieces.
4. Vintage Rose O’Neill Kewpie and Turkey Single Salt Pepper Shaker
dede123beagle / eBay
Value: $332.78
Why it’s valuable: This single 1930s German-made shaker pairs a beloved Rose O’Neill Kewpie figure with a turkey. Its rarity, age and endearing design helped it fetch a high price at auction.
3. Vintage Thanksgiving Blow Mold Set
risingphoenixonthenet / eBay
Value: $349
Why it’s valuable: This Don Featherstone set includes large Pilgrim figures nearly three feet tall plus a lighted turkey. The complete set, in good working condition, is a rare find and commands strong collector demand.
2. Christopher Radko Harvest Turkey Centerpiece Cookie Jar
kevtmmy5 / eBay
Value: $388
Why it’s valuable: Christopher Radko is a respected name in collectible holiday decor. This 2002 cookie jar, never used and in pristine condition, mirrors Radko’s signature festive style and commands a high price among collectors.
1. Vintage Porcelain Modernist Turkey
burgess2020 / eBay
Value: $525
Why it’s valuable: This modernist porcelain turkey from Cmielow, Poland, dates to the 1950s. Measuring roughly 3.5 by 5 inches, its minimalist, midcentury design and the reputation of Cmielow porcelain helped it become the most valuable Thanksgiving collectible on this list.
These items illustrate how varied and unexpectedly valuable Thanksgiving collectibles can be—from postcards and paper die-cuts to large blow molds and handcrafted centerpieces. If you inherit or discover vintage holiday decor, it may be worth researching its origin and condition before discarding, as you might be holding a piece many collectors would love to add to their displays.